20 Comments
User's avatar
Mark E Johnson's avatar

I had heard rumors of this event before, but never the real story. Thanks, Tara, for clearing up the matter! It's wonderful that neither was seriously injured and that their differences were, at least in part, settled. Oh that we all could walk away from anger and settle our hurts easily!!!

Expand full comment
Virginia Ross's avatar

Maybe a dumb question, but under 'the' Liberty Tree - where? In Boston?

Expand full comment
Barb's avatar

I don't think it's dumb. I have the same question! Thanks for asking it!

Expand full comment
Samuel Vanderburg's avatar

Actually, almost every town that had a committee of correspondence had a liberty tree. This included Georgia and South Carolina. So the location was likely in Georgia. Likely Augusta was the local. I think Augusta was not yet controlled by the British but Savanna was.

Expand full comment
JimmyinTEXAS's avatar

Yes it was in Boston.

Expand full comment
Wally Firkins's avatar

Wow. Another story that I haven't heard, Tara. The manner in which the duel was conducted is very interesting. Two reluctant combatants. I wonder why it wasn't General Washington's job to appoint the General in charge of the South Carolina troops and to arbitrate the dispute between Gadsden and Howe?

Also, was Gadsdens military career over at this point? Thank you, Tara.

Expand full comment
Patty's avatar

A duel that never happened! There are certainly better ways to settle disagreements. Seems like both men didn’t really want to take the other man’s life. The best part is Gadsden later advocated for laws to prevent dueling.

Expand full comment
Sandy Schultz's avatar

Both gentlemen apparently realized that killing one another was not the answer. Oh that people today would be that mature!

Expand full comment
JimmyinTEXAS's avatar

You inferred you knew the answer when you used the term gentlemen.

Expand full comment
Paula's avatar

Love this story! I’m always amazed at how people, imperfect as they are..can finally come together for a common cause..we need to build on this now!

Expand full comment
Samuel Vanderburg's avatar

An appropriate ending to a duel for once!

Expand full comment
Jack Miller's avatar

Maybe the beginning of the end of duels. A good thing if it was. Glad they chose to not kill each other.

Expand full comment
Edward Jones's avatar

❤️🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

Expand full comment
Dan's avatar

👍👍👍

Expand full comment
David Brumbaugh's avatar

Good grief.....when I first began to read the lesson, I had forgotten about the American General Howe! So my brain is trying to figure out how an Amercan General was having a duel with a British General DURING the war for independence! I think that I need more coffee. Regardless, Tara Ross,thank you for the lesson.

It does show that personal vanity and ego created serious animosity between members of the same fighting force, and that is dangerous.

Expand full comment
Tv's avatar

First I'm learning of this.

Thanks, TR!

Seems a man's reputation mattered a great deal back then, but not worth a life to these men.

Expand full comment
Frank Furno's avatar

What a hoot! Thank you, Tara! 🇺🇸

Expand full comment
Jim's avatar

A very interesting way to end the duel, perhaps when push came to shove neither man truly wanted it! Thanks Tara 😊

Expand full comment
Mike Masterson's avatar

I sometimes wish we still had dueling...🤔

Expand full comment
Johnny Baker Jr. MLA's avatar

I prefer the way Andrew Jackson dueled!

Expand full comment